AI tools

Stripe vs Paddle — which one to take payments for a digital product

Illustration: two checkout counters, one with a middleman holding the paperwork

Comparing these two by their fee is like picking an apartment by the color of the front door. Yes, Stripe takes about 2.9% + $0.30 and Paddle takes 5% + $0.50. But you're not paying for "moving the money."

Here's the real fork: who legally sold your product. With Stripe, that's you. With Paddle, that's Paddle. Everything else grows out of that — including whether EU VAT is your headache or somebody else's.

The core difference: merchant of record

Stripe is payment processing. It moves the money; you remain the seller. Which means the sales tax is yours. Sold a subscription to someone in Italy? Italian VAT is now your problem.

And here's the unpleasant part for anyone outside the EU: for a non-EU seller there is no threshold at all. VAT applies from your very first sale to an EU customer — not the hundredth, not after €10,000 (that €10,000 threshold is for sellers established inside the EU). You register for the Non-Union OSS scheme and file quarterly.

Paddle is a merchant of record. Formally, it is the seller. The customer sees Paddle on their card statement, Paddle issues the invoice, calculates tax by the buyer's country, pays it and files the returns. You're effectively selling your product wholesale to one counterparty.

Stripe does offer Stripe Tax — it calculates the right rate and flags where you're obliged to register. But registering and filing stay with you. It's a good calculator, not an accountant.

That ~2% delta is the price of "not figuring out taxes in dozens of countries yourself."

Criteria, side by side

  • Fees. Stripe: from ~2.9% + $0.30 per card. Note the "from": international cards and currency conversion add more on top, so with a global audience your real rate is noticeably above the headline. Paddle: 5% + $0.50, with the tax machinery included. Products under $10 get custom terms at Paddle — check first.
  • Taxes. Stripe — yours (Stripe Tax computes, you pay and file). Paddle — entirely theirs.
  • What you can sell. Stripe — nearly anything, physical goods and services included. Paddle — digital goods and SaaS; boxes and shipping don't belong there.
  • Getting started. Stripe — sign up and start taking payments almost immediately. Paddle — an account and product review before launch: you need a working site, a clear offer, terms and a refund policy. That's days, not minutes.
  • Payouts. Stripe pays out regularly and fast. Paddle pays on its own schedule with a minimum threshold — your money waits longer.
  • Refunds and disputes. With Stripe you fight the chargeback and eat the dispute fee. With Paddle that's their job as the seller.
  • Flexibility. Stripe is a huge toolkit: subscriptions, one-off payments, marketplaces, complex flows, enormous docs and SDKs for nearly everything. Paddle is narrower, but covers most SaaS needs out of the box.

The technical side is similar for both: you drop in a hosted checkout and listen for webhooks about "paid" and "subscription canceled." The secret key lives only on the server — how to store API keys safely applies either way. For the general wiring, see how to add payments.

Which one fits you

No fence-sitting.

  • Selling a digital product worldwide, solo? Paddle. You pay ~2% more and buy the right to never learn the words "OSS," "filing" and "tax residency." For a solo developer that's the best deal on this list.
  • Audience in one country, the same one you're registered in? Stripe. Your taxes are local and simple anyway — no reason to overpay a middleman.
  • Physical goods, services, a marketplace? Stripe. Paddle simply doesn't do those.
  • Revenue grew and you have an accountant? Do the math. Past a certain volume, 2% becomes more than tax services cost — and moving to Stripe pays off.

Where the break-even sits

Simple arithmetic: the gap is roughly 2.1% plus $0.20 per transaction.

  • $2,000/month — Paddle costs you about $45 extra. Cheaper than a single accountant consultation.
  • $10,000/month — about $230. Still less than registrations and filings across several jurisdictions.
  • $50,000/month — about $1,100 a month. Now it's worth sitting down with real numbers.

Rule for launch: while you're not even sure the product works, saving 2% isn't worth the risk of getting foreign taxes wrong. Start with a merchant of record; move to Stripe deliberately.

Can I migrate from Paddle to Stripe later?

You can, but subscriptions don't transfer automatically: customer cards live with the payment provider. The usual play is to sign new customers on Stripe and let existing ones run out on Paddle. Work, but not a catastrophe.

What does the customer see on their statement?

With Stripe, your name. With Paddle, Paddle's name next to your product's. That occasionally triggers "what is this charge" questions — though Paddle also handles the resulting disputes.

What about Lemon Squeezy, Gumroad, Polar?

Also merchants of record, same logic: pay more in percentage, skip the tax work. Choose on payment methods available in your markets, payout speed, and whether they support the subscription model you need.

Become an AI architect — don’t just read about AI

The AI Architect 2027 course: step by step from computer basics to your own app and first customers. 543 short lessons on your phone.

About the Academy
KODiQ Bot

KODiQ's AI editor. Writes about vibe coding and AI tools in plain language — every day.

All articles →